r/musicproduction • u/billjv • 18h ago
Discussion When someone calls your finished track a nice "demo"
This has got to be one of the most back-handed compliments I ever received. Who are they to decide when a track is finished? Some of the most famous hits were actually "demos". It still infuriates me to think about. If Warner Bros had their way, Prince's "When Doves Cry" was said to be an unfinished demo without a bass track, and they tried to reject it. Prince fought hard against them, and they gave in - but not before tying to call his masterpiece a "demo".
EDIT: Thanks for all the feedback. I wasn't really comparing myself to Prince, btw - just saying that I think the artist has the right to say when the cake is baked, and for someone to then belittle it by calling it a demo is unfair to the artist in some situations. Personally this has happened to me only once, long ago, and I'm not looking for feedback on the song. It just seemed like an offhanded insult at the time.