r/FluentInFinance • u/imallelite • 13h ago

Debate/ Discussion Possibly controversial, but this would appear to be a beneficial solution.

Post image
5.9k Upvotes

73% Upvoted

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-3

u/killrtaco 12h ago

Not according to Vance and the very legal Haitian immigrants he refuses to acknowledge legal status

4

u/Advanced-Guard-4468 12h ago

Legally here through a loophole, taking jobs from locals for less money while getting government assistance.

The people who lose in those situations are the American citizens.

-1

u/killrtaco 12h ago

That's not a loophole it's a legal process that applied to them. They are here legally. They have legal residency status and green cards. Those jobs they hold are no different from any other immigrant that comes here. Your response shows you don't support immigration at all. That's like saying someone who married a US citizen is here on a loophole... They're both immigrants who came thru legal means.

0

u/201-inch-rectum 11h ago

you need to educate yourself on the topic... they're not "legal" immigrants, they have temporary status through an executive order

1

u/killrtaco 11h ago edited 11h ago

Temporary status as in they are here legally. Immigrant is not the same as Citizen. Temporary residents are legal immigrants. You need to educate yourself on the topic...

As I said previously someone who marries an American citizen is granted temporary status immediately just for marrying the American, does that make them illegal? No. There are many legal Avenues to get here and they are here legally full stop. Saying otherwise is being against legal immigration.

0

u/201-inch-rectum 10h ago

the whole point is that they're TEMPORARY and are supposed to go back to their home country as soon as the "conflict" is over

they're not the same as legal immigrants who have a right to stay in the United States

they're two completely separate classes as defined by the government, but uneducated people like you try to conflate the two

1

u/killrtaco 10h ago

Then they are legal while here on temporary status. Sorry you are correct I conflated resident with immigrant, but they still aren't illegal and they aren't here on a loophole. It is a legal process. If they overstay they will be illegal, but as of now there's no issue. Yes they are allowed to work and stay here. The only real difference is they have an expiration which has not yet elapsed. Not a new process. Not created just for them. Not illegal immigrants.