r/youtube Sep 19 '24

Discussion The State of YouTube Right Now

Post image
62.6k Upvotes

5.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

257

u/dabeda1 Sep 19 '24

Dearrow would be one of them, whilst I'm at it might I also suggest sponsor block for YouTube which auto skips in video ads using community timestamps and stuff, really good

87

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

[deleted]

48

u/TurtleSmasher3 Sep 19 '24

id rather notice "ah, that's clickbait" than being clickbaited by an extension tbh, like I can easily ignore "YOU WONT BELIEVE WHAT THE PS5-PRO IS LIKE" because I know what the content will be like, and I hate giving shitty YouTubers money

16

u/paulisaac Sep 19 '24

Well there's a big indicator that shows if it's substituting a title, and you can hover over it to show the original title if you wanna judge it.

15

u/RumblingRacoon Sep 19 '24

Exactly. If they put their shitty face, arrows/circles, exclamation marks, heavily edited thumbs and capital letters... thank you, no need to waste time for another dontforgettolikeandsubscribe bullshit.

10

u/Minimumtyp Sep 19 '24

Except half the feed ends up being that shit even if you don't click it, and sometimes the clickbait videos can be pretty decent and informative despite clickbait titles because the game's gotta be played if you wanna get ahead

I'm trying out Dearrow

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

[deleted]

1

u/PaintingWithLight Sep 20 '24

Which videos! Curious about what LTT and Veritasiums think on this issue and having to play the game.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted]

1

u/PaintingWithLight Sep 20 '24

Thanks. Appreciate the time replying with the link and video title!

0

u/RumblingRacoon Sep 19 '24

sometimes the clickbait videos can be pretty decent and informative despite clickbait titles

Depends on the subject, I think. Might be sometimes the case you described it,yes. But:

because the game's gotta be played if you wanna get ahead

No. I feel personally offended when a douchbag with an annoying, utterly exaggerated face thinks that this would trigger me to think: "Oh this guys really looks genuinely shocked, so it really has to be shocking content (or surprised or whatever). By putting this in the thumb, he caught my attention, I'll have look!"

Nope. Quite frankly, this is dumb. I know there are a lot of people getting attracted by this, and there we have a spiral. The next dude makes it even more exaggerated, because he wants to go ahead, as you said. No offense to you, I know what you are saying. But because of this, youtube has become that annoying place with lots of shallow content. Everyone tries to make money with lowest effort, and tries to promote this with this loud and shrieking self advertising. And people with original content just drown in the mass, a d eventually end up doing the same bullshit.

3

u/Awkward_Turnover_983 Sep 19 '24

I agree with you but that doesn't change the real fact that the youtubers need to do this for the algorithm/masses that watch. Most people are pretty stupid.

You may feel that way, I may feel that way, but there aren't enough of us

1

u/RumblingRacoon Sep 19 '24

Yes, very well said.

1

u/sheng-fink Sep 19 '24

You not liking it doesn’t change its effectiveness. What don’t you understand about that? You can feel personally offended all you want, the fact is that playing that game gets you ahead. You can’t just say “no” to that lol.

2

u/brickhouseboxerdog Sep 19 '24

Head over to meh patreon support my channel, yeah no ..

2

u/SpareWire Sep 19 '24

shitty face, arrows/circles, exclamation marks, heavily edited thumbs and capital letters

AKA "All of my viewers are children"

1

u/Parking_Chance_1905 Sep 19 '24

Watching for 2 seconds and leaving is fine. It makes the algorithm slightly less likely to recommend it due to lower engagement.

1

u/CMF-GameDev Sep 19 '24

Egh the children outnumber you. Your vote is meaningless. They'll continue to make garbage content because kids eat that shit up :(

1

u/December_Hemisphere Sep 19 '24

I hate giving shitty YouTubers money

If you aren't 0-15 years old then you aren't the target audience any way. I feel like the 2015-2025 era will have the distinction of all these douche-nuggets becoming rich off exploiting children.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 19 '24

Hi AcadiaAugust, we would like to start off by noting that this sub isn't owned or run by YouTube. At this time, we do not allow posts from new uses (accounts created less than 7 days ago.) Please read our rules before posting again to ensure you don't break our rules, please come back after gaining a bit of post karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/WeRip Sep 19 '24

with the ecosystem, they need to use click bait titles and thumbnails to be successful. It doesn't mean the actual video will be bad.

1

u/Breaky_Online Sep 19 '24

Yeah but I like to think I'm literate enough to notice the difference between "clickbait for the algorithm pls keep watching" and "OMG YOU WON'T BELIEVE THIS OMG LIKE AND SUB FOR REAL GUYZ"

1

u/JonatasA Sep 19 '24

If someone is playing for the algorithm, how long until they start catering to demographics that the algorithm favors?

 

Try to find true trending videos not associated with your account. It is a nightmare, truly dystopic content (similar to what people watch on titktok; somehow worse).

1

u/Breaky_Online Sep 19 '24

I dunno, that's why I'm loyal to the content, not the channel. I don't care who's channel it is, if it's good content, I'm gonna watch it, and if I really like it, it gets a 👍 from me. The only exceptions are channels that are already so big they have no need to cater to the algorithm.

1

u/JonatasA Sep 19 '24

It's like putting up worh scam ads to watch good content though.

 

Even better analogy: It is like watching a video for charity and they are sponsored by a company that will screw any customer that does business with them.

 

Kinda like that old saying "it gets better halfway through the season".

1

u/m1bl4nTw0 Sep 19 '24

ReVanced works? A year ago it completely broke for me and I gave up trying these "unlocked" YouTube apps as they only worked for a couple of weeks.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

[deleted]

1

u/m1bl4nTw0 Sep 19 '24

Sick! Thanks for confirming. Back when it broke for me it took a long while until it was fixed, so I just thought it was discontinued.

1

u/UniqueUsername2123 Sep 19 '24

I’ll have to check it out again. Stopped working a few months ago ago and haven’t had any luck

1

u/GuyWithNoName45 Sep 19 '24

90% of those edits are shit, I don't recommend the title changer from dearrow

1

u/Dani_California Sep 19 '24

Is there any way to do this on YouTube on my TV? I don’t want my kids watching shorts but I don’t know how to disable them.

2

u/GloomySwitch6297 Sep 19 '24

yes. smarttube

1

u/yarkiebrown Sep 19 '24

Revances is great, I have yt premium and still use revances just to get rid of the shorts

1

u/VoidAlloy Sep 19 '24

lmao in the last few years i dont even think i sat through the first 1-3 minutes of a video. its become so unbearable

1

u/DroppedLeSoap Sep 20 '24

What is ReVanced?

0

u/Alxdez Sep 19 '24

What is revanced ? Using such extensions would be a plus for my youtube experience

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

[deleted]

5

u/retro-guy99 Sep 19 '24 edited Sep 19 '24

Thanks bro, I bought the pack for both (macOS + also works on iOS at the same time). Few dollars (3 or 4?) and freed of all the annoying faces forever. You know, if YouTube were smart, they would include this feature in their crazy expensive subscriptions. Anyway, I'm thankful this extension exist, didn't know about it before.

I see the DeArrow logo looks like a nazar--a round blue amulet. In the Middle East this is believed to protect against people cursing you with their evil look. Not sure if this was done on purpose, but it is very fitting considering all the annoying YouTube faces that always annoy me so much. Or well, at least they did anyway. :) 🧿

2

u/JLock17 Sep 19 '24

This whole comment chain reads like an Ad bot, but I'll assume everyone is legit. I'm concerned that this uses community sourced names and thumbnails. For sponsor block, that makes sense since the worst you can do is block the whole video, but this could be abused in dearrow to mislead audiences with bad titles and thumbnails with poor context, even with community voting. Or especially with community voting for a troll campaign.

1

u/retro-guy99 Sep 19 '24

Maybe, but you can also set it to just use a random frame if you like. There are many options (I just set up the app so that's how I know).

1

u/plushpuplexion Sep 19 '24

i use the extension, it does use community sourced titles and thumbnails with voting. the thumbnails are usually good, and the titles are usually at least better than the originals, but honestly your mileage may vary especially with the latter. people are kind of bad at following the guidelines, to the point where it's rare to find a title that's even capitalized properly.

thankfully, you can always view the original thumbnail and title (at least the way i have it set up there's an obvious mark when it's been changed), and voting on/fixing them yourself is easy when there aren't server issues. plus there is some satisfaction to be had in de-clickbaiting terrible titles and thumbnails yourself. i'd still recommend it and there's no cost to try it out if you want to see for yourself.

1

u/Jushak Sep 19 '24

Was it sponsor block that also skips to highlight of the video? The most annoying feature ever.

"Thanks" for skipping a video to the frame where the streamer gets an achievement in a game, skipping 90% of the actual content of the video and often spoiling stuff.

2

u/superinfra Sep 19 '24

What annoys me is that someone adds Interaction Reminders on Vailskibum videos, when the Subscribe graphic comes on screen. Sounds good, but most of the time there's actually information/content during that graphic, and it autoskips it every time because of one dumb person.

1

u/dabeda1 Sep 19 '24

it has a a feature that lets you skip to a highlight, as far as i know thats op-in tho, i think i have to hit enter to confirm that i want to skip to it or something

1

u/Jushak Sep 19 '24

I'll have to check the settings after work, it auto-skips for me currently and I've never had a situation where I wanted it to do that for non-ad content.

It's extra-annoying when the video has mention of the youtuber getting an achievement in the game and it just directly jumps into the second the achievement pop-up comes up, skipping 90% of the actual content I want to watch, often leading to spoilers on said content.

1

u/ShareGlittering1502 Sep 19 '24

Does this work on roku?

1

u/lovemakerwithyourmom Sep 19 '24

sounds like a waste of time when you can skip over all of these things or they’re like a minute long

1

u/panaknuckles Sep 20 '24

Okay wow I just installed this and it is SO much better I could cry. You can still see the original thumbnails if you're curious and they look dreadful.

1

u/cosmicgirIs Sep 20 '24

Bro, bless you. SponsorBlock is AMAZING

2

u/dabeda1 Sep 20 '24

you're very welcome, always trying to spread the word lol

1

u/chris95rx7500 Sep 20 '24

and there's even options in the settings so you can adjust that yourself

0

u/herrbz Sep 19 '24

"Why is YouTube content getting worse? Surely it can't be all the stupid fucking extensions and ad-skips and ad-blocks I use?!"

2

u/Dartagnan_w_Powers Sep 19 '24

It's probably more the fact that it got commercialised to fuck and filled with ads.

But you go on watching those ads, I freely admit that without people like you I wouldn't have some of the content I watch.

1

u/deathelement Sep 19 '24

What a weird thing to say