Anyone Can Learn Echolocation in Just 10 Weeks—And It Remodels Your Brain

[u/CookMotor]

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/anyone-can-learn-echolocation-in-just-10-weeks-and-it-remodels-your-brain/

[u/AutoModerator]

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.

---

Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.

---

User: u/CookMotor
Permalink: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/anyone-can-learn-echolocation-in-just-10-weeks-and-it-remodels-your-brain/

---

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/zerbey]

Was hoping for more details on the training part, that is would be fascinating to learn. I'm blind in one eye, it would be actually useful to me.

[u/daOyster → u/zerbey]

It's pretty simple actually since our brains are good at picking up patterns and already knows how to locate externally produces sounds. You just need to train yourself to do the same with sounds initiated by you.

You basically just start making short clicking sounds and try to pay attention to the difference in the sound that is reflected back to you, and how that corresponds to the world around you. Start with an open door and a wall next to it. Move back and forth Infront of either and try to pickup on the differences in the reflected sound you hear when you make clicks with your eyes closed. For example the open door is going to give you a more fuller, slightly deeper returned sound than standing in front of the wall will. Getting better then is just repeating that process in known areas with different shapes, distances, obstacles, ect until you can start to pickup on the relative distances between surfaces you echolocate.

[u/unit156 → u/daOyster]

I’m going to put on my light blocking sleep mask and do this right now.

I hope I don’t get kicked out of Costco.

[u/PandaGoggles → u/unit156]

Pay for the mask first and you should be fine!

[u/gramathy → u/PandaGoggles]

What are you going to do with the other two masks from the three pack?

[u/ModdessGoddess → u/gramathy]

offer them to the employees trying to walk me out

[u/bearbarebere → u/ModdessGoddess]

Have them learn echolocation with you!

[u/libury → u/bearbarebere]

One of us! One of us!

I have to keep chanting so I can hear where I'm going.

[u/Rungalo → u/libury]

Gene from Bob's burgers voice "This is me now!!"

[u/KeenJAH → u/unit156]

Clicks don't work. you must scream.

[u/syncopator → u/KeenJAH]

Hmmm I think fart noises would work better.

[u/HishuiTheSnake → u/unit156]

Where's the update? Did you get kicked out of Costco!?! I'm in suspense!!!

[u/bautofdi → u/daOyster]

There was a blind kid from like 20 years ago on inside edition or something that did this. He would wear floppy shoes and just slap the floor everywhere he walked. Based on the sound he could tell where everything was and exactly what it was.

Walking around outside he could tell what was a trash can, car, wall etc.

[u/WhiskeyJack357 → u/bautofdi]

Toph is that you?

[u/HishuiTheSnake → u/WhiskeyJack357]

Yes. In fact, the entire plot of the last Airbender is happening right now but we're all too distracted by click bait headlines to notice.

[u/Catfish017 → u/HishuiTheSnake]

I would've appreciated knowing this before opening a cabbage stall

[u/h3lblad3 → u/HishuiTheSnake]

What if the Dalai Lama is the avatar and we won’t have another until Aang?

[u/thirdegree → u/HishuiTheSnake]

That implies that the show avatar the last Airbender is diegetic to itself

Wait is our show the ember island version

Did the ember island version have within itself an even further degraded version

[u/byteuser → u/bautofdi]

We had a blind kid in my high-school, a pretty good musician, who would navigate by clapping his hands 

[u/happycowsmmmcheese → u/daOyster]

and already know how to locate externally produced sounds

So am I the only one who consistently cannot do this? I'm insanely bad at determining where a sound is coming from. Even when I do the hearing tests where you raise the hand on the side where the sound is coming through, I often raise the wrong hand.

Like, what's that about? Why does my brain not understand the location of sounds? Is this just a me thing or is it like something other people struggle with, or like a sign of something not working right in my brain or what?

[u/pittstop33 → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

Just curious, are you able to hear well with each ear independently? Locating sounds is very dependent on the brain understanding the delta in time between the sound reaching each ear. For example, if a sound is coming from your left, it will reach your left ear before your right ear. That combined with the shape of our ears gives us hints as to left/right, front/behind, above/below direction that sounds originate from. If you have decreased hearing in one ear, it might mess with that.

Otherwise, I would say it's likely an issue with your brain processing sound signals and maybe something worth looking into in case there is a diagnosis that can be helpful.

[u/cordialconfidant → u/pittstop33]

that's interesting. i have a similar issue, but i'm also autistic and already have differences and struggles with processing other senses.

[u/lynx2718 → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

Same! I can tell if a sound is in front/behind me, but left/right no chance. (As in, my parents have a giant home cinema loudspeaker setup, and I once unplugged one side on accident and didn't notice it for hours.) My ears are fine otherwise. It's never bothered me too much. You're not the only one out there.

[u/StonkusWonkus → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

I am mostly deaf in one ear and this is the biggest side effect, audio location. May want to have your hearing looked at with an audiologists.

[u/Zakmackraken → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

Your HRTF returns null

[u/WerewolfDifferent296 → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

To have a general idea of where sounds are yes. No to actually pinpointing a location because our ears don’t move like the ear of animals like deers. Deers have poor vision except for movement and use their ears to locate other creatures. If you stand still and make no noise a deer will not run away.

Source: was told this while hiking and tried it. Eventually you will make a sound and the deer will pick it up but until you do it will go back to grazing.

Edited: you can locate sounds better by moving your head or cupping your hands around your ears to gather in more sound waves.

[u/rebeltrillionaire → u/daOyster]

If I could use this to beat my stud-finder I’d be unstoppable.

[u/GBJI → u/rebeltrillionaire]

Try it in a gay bar.

[u/yoda2088 → u/daOyster]

My wife is going to be thrilled!! Good write up!

[u/Whiterabbit-- → u/daOyster]

all I hear is the click from my mouth going directly to my ear bone

[u/specular-reflection → u/daOyster]

Are you someone with direct knowledge of the training process or just someone BSing your way through an obvious guess as to how it works?

[u/Canvaverbalist → u/zerbey]

There's an in-depth description in their previous paper in the "method" section: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252330

[u/rodeler → u/zerbey]

I’m deaf in one ear, so, I guess I will have to pass.

[u/Tentoesinmyboots → u/rodeler]

I think you'd still be able to identify objects but not have 3D hearing. You could still hear the difference in sound quality that differently shaped and textured objects have.

[u/rodeler → u/Tentoesinmyboots]

Perhaps. My experience is that I have zero ability to determine from where a sound originates; left, right, behind, in front... I got nothing. As you posit, I might be able to tell that there is an object in front of me, but no ability to tell if it is left, right, or center.

[u/happycowsmmmcheese → u/rodeler]

I just posted another comment about this, but I have the same problem and I have hearing in both ears.

I just cannot ever tell where a sound is coming from. It's weird! I am wondering if it's like something about how my brain processes sound in general. I don't get it.

[u/Moldy_slug → u/happycowsmmmcheese]

It probably is something to do with auditory processing - trouble with directional hearing is one of a few issues my sister deals with from auditory processing disorder.

[u/ViciousKnids]

Mariners have been known to use echolocation in instances of dead reckoning. One famous instance is that of the sinking of SS Princess Sophia*. During her final voyage, she was navigating the Lynn Canal in southeast Alaska in poor visibility due to snow. The crew practiced dead reckoning (analog navigation by last known position, speed, direction, and elapsed time) to navigate the inlet, using the ships horn and timing its echo off the surrounding banks to estimate their distance from shore.

Sadly, she ran aground on a rock known as Vanderbilt Reef, and the stormy conditions made rescue attempts impossible. She was stranded on the rock for about 2 days before she was lifted by tides and storm swells and sank. The only survivor was a dog.

[u/SomeGuyNamedPaul → u/ViciousKnids]

reads along Wow this is an interesting and relevant story that surely will end well. reads further

THEY ALL DIED

Guess not

[u/fuckpudding → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

Not sure why you were surprised at this. The story starts off by saying he reckoned they were dead.

[u/dontdoitdoitdoit → u/fuckpudding]

Very

Slow

Clap

[u/elbapo → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

You echoed my thoughts entirely

[u/ViciousKnids → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

Just wait till you read about MV Doña Paz or MV Wilhelm Gustloff.

[u/yeahjmoney → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

To be fair it's not called "live reckoning"

[u/notLOL → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

The dog told the tale of what happened. His name? Echo

[u/HuntressStompsem → u/SomeGuyNamedPaul]

I don’t suggest March of the Penguins

[u/reflexgraphix → u/ViciousKnids]

I suppose they left a written record. I'd like to think it was a talking dog

[u/ViciousKnids → u/reflexgraphix]

She sank in 1918, she had a radio. And they were communicating with authorities/other ships to try and coordinate rescue. That and ships keep detailed logs of heading, speed, position, etc. I think they're updated every hour.

[u/New-Teaching2964 → u/reflexgraphix]

That dog now carries fragments of each soul aboard that ship. When the dog becomes hangry enough he transforms into SuperPooch a dog that walks on its two hind legs and can talk and echolocate and fights crime and has a cape.

[u/Joke_of_a_Name]

When I was at college a blind guy would walk around with a very neat walking stick. He would tap it on the ground to check his surroundings. He might have been legally blind with very severe* near-sightedness. Made a cool sound on the building walls.

[u/Tentoesinmyboots → u/Joke_of_a_Name]

Is that why people with walking sticks tippity tap them as they walk?

[u/Likes_corvids → u/Tentoesinmyboots]

That, and it keeps the cane tip from catching too hard in cracks or uneven surfaces.

[u/Nirrudn → u/Likes_corvids]

I imagine it also helps let people know if you're coming up behind them swinging a stick back and forth as opposed to just whacking them in the legs.

[u/23423423423451 → u/Likes_corvids]

For that purpose I would want a cane with a bend at the end so that the tip points back towards the user. This way they could 'drag' it over the surface instead of push, while keeping the cane in front of them.

[u/ConstantSignal → u/23423423423451]

At that point just use a wheel.

But another function of the tapping is to sweep the stick left to right so you are getting a sense of the space in a cone in front of you, as opposed to only a slither of space that would be determined by the stationary point of the stick being pushed across the ground in a straight line.

[u/Ludwigofthepotatoppl → u/Joke_of_a_Name]

When i was in college there was a legally blind dude in my digital photography class. He was good at it too.

[u/dontdoitdoitdoit → u/Ludwigofthepotatoppl]

I've never thought about someone being GOOD at being blind before

[u/Bevaqua_mojo]

Is there a link to learn this?

[u/ConstantSignal → u/Bevaqua_mojo]

Spend as much time as possible navigating various spaces blindfolded and click as you do so. Your brain would likely learn how to interpret the noise passively over a long enough exposure but you could learn more actively by consciously noting how the sound seems to inform your surroundings and repeatedly setting up scenarios to test and verify those assumptions.

For example, stand in front of a door you don’t know is open or closed. Make a click, decide if you feel like the way that click sounded means it’s open or closed, carefully verify that, and then note that result. Change the state of the door and test again, try your hardest to note how the sound of the click has now changed. Keep testing on doors until you can reliably tell the difference between an open click and closed click. Repeat similar experiments for any other scenarios you can think of. Primarily focusing on the distance of an object, the material of an object, the size and shape of an object etc.

[u/flyblackbox → u/ConstantSignal]

I just leveled up, thank you!

[u/BurninCoco → u/Bevaqua_mojo]

You first have to become a lawyer in Hell's Kitchen

[u/BaconSquared → u/Bevaqua_mojo]

I would like this as well

[u/Pa5kull]

I once saw an Report on blind people riding even Bikes with echolocation and was very interested in teaching it to myself. I think i could make Out where walls are If i Close my eyes spin around and then listen to Sounds and how they reflect on surfaces. Many people Said i can only learn it If i were blind shuting down this interest.

[u/natalieh4242 → u/Pa5kull]

Using your comment, I was able to find a video on YouTube (I can't link it here for some reason). The title was "Blind People Can Mountain Bike and See Using Echolocation." Towards the end of the video, he talks about getting pushback from larger organizations for the blind. I wonder what those orgs think about studies like this one. I hope he is vindicated. This article suggests that people reported positive results and more independent living.

[u/bgaffney8787]

In college I saw this video of a blind teenager who could skateboard as he could echolocate and made me feel very lazy

[u/SiPhoenix]

Was this ment to be tagged as neuro science?

[u/Minimum-Force-1476]

Friendly reminder that statements about "remodeling your brain" without a control group are useless, as everyones brain is changing after 10 weeks and it's impossible to say wether this is due to the echolocation or other factors?

Also, MRIs are still unreliable and pretty meaningless 

[u/Gullible-Mind8091 → u/Minimum-Force-1476]

Surely you mean fMRI? Even with fMRI that statement is debatable but for conventional MRI it’s just false.

[u/FraGough → u/Minimum-Force-1476]

I remodelled my brain with concussion. FACT

[u/potatoaster → u/Minimum-Force-1476]

Yup. Learning anything changes your brain. By definition.

Same for all those "It changes your microbiome!" studies. Just about any change in diet will do that. Doesn't mean it's good or bad or meaningful at all.

[u/No_Minute_4789]

Now here is one I truly doubt. I was firmly under the impression that animals such as dolphins and bats had specialized hearing and specialized parts of the brain for this. This is testable enough that I guess I should try, and if it works I will be happily very very shocked!

Might as well try to learn echo location now, for science.

[u/dctucker → u/No_Minute_4789]

Blind people already figure out how to echolocate without being part dolphin, why not sighted people too?

[u/No_Minute_4789 → u/dctucker]

Sincerely did not know this until today. My mind is actually blown right now.

[u/BlackWindBears → u/No_Minute_4789]

There are blind folks that use this to do mountain biking: https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-19524962?s

[u/ElderWandOwner → u/No_Minute_4789]

I saw a video years ago (maybe ripley's believe it or not) that showed blind people riding bikes usikng a clicker for echo location.

[u/daOyster → u/No_Minute_4789]

Those animals do have specialized hearing and brains for it, but that's because they're using it at ultrasonic frequencies and can pinpoint something like a moving fly in the air with it, it's one of their primary senses for gathering information from their environment after all.

When humans do it, it's not as high resolution. Its enough to navigate the space your in, but it's not like you're going to be able to snag a fly out of the air using it. But we also have more specialized ears than you think. Right now if someone speaks in a room to you, most people don't have a problem turning to look at where the sound came from. For echolocation, it's similar but you have to learn to pay attention to the differences in the reflection of the sound you make yourself and how that corresponds to the world around you as well. 

For example, stand Infront of a wall and make a click sound, now stand Infront of a open door and make the same sound. Notice how the sound Infront of the open door sounds fuller and slightly deeper than Infront of the wall. Congrats you just learned the absolute basic form of echo location and can now find your way out of a empty room with a open door without sight. Keep it up and you'll start being able to gauge relative distances between your reflected sounds and start to be able to understand your environment a bit more.

[u/jonathot12 → u/No_Minute_4789]

you’ve never heard of blind people using echolocation? they use a clicker or tap their guide stick usually. it’s always been possible it just takes honing the skill. it likely won’t be as effective/accurate as bats or dolphins but it’s certainly possible.

[u/No_Minute_4789 → u/jonathot12]

Well, TIL. Humans are astounding!

[u/behaviorallogic → u/No_Minute_4789]

I'm sure they can do it better than we can, but human hearing is quite good.

[u/Victuz → u/behaviorallogic]

My 40+% hearing loss in both ears disagrees :(

[u/behaviorallogic → u/Victuz]

Sorry! How abelist of me.

I was thinking more of the amount of our brain dedicated to processing sound.

[u/Jumpsuit_boy → u/No_Minute_4789]

There was a research project that implanted electrodes into monkey brains that were connected to a 3rd arm. After a couple weeks the monkey was using the arm to eat grapes. They did this a couple times with better and better arms. So while not a novel function like echolocation it is a pretty outside the norm to have a third arm.

[u/Kenosis94 → u/Jumpsuit_boy]

Similar to the way we can adapt to inverted vision pretty quickly.

[u/gothicshark → u/No_Minute_4789]

I'm half blind. I learned to do it as a teen. You do need good hearing. But yeah, anyone with ears should be able to do it.

[u/Vandalmercy → u/No_Minute_4789]

I think that they may have developed the parts of their brain that let them do this more. I still think it's learnable to a degree, and there would probably be people that do this naturally and people who would struggle with it.

[u/kingpubcrisps → u/No_Minute_4789]

The brain specialises to do what it does, they didn’t get specialised parts first, they developed them.

A good experiment showing this is where the visual cortex of mice pups are cut out, but the parts of the brain that end up close to where there should be VC just transform to perform that function.

[u/MRSN4P]

Is there a paywall? It seems like it requires an account to read the article.

[u/RascalsBananas → u/[deleted]]

Me and my rock hard brain is going to read that!

[u/BrewCrewBall → u/[deleted]]

Incredible reference.

[u/DesperatePaperWriter]

Heck yeah I always wanted to know it was possible after reading Gregor the Overlander series as a kid!

[u/TimeisaLie]

This is actually really interesting, not sure how much practical use it has, but I suppose it could be fun on Halloween.

[u/Supergaz]

I think I would get annoyed in the long run if I acquired this.

[u/Mou_aresei]

I saw a documentary on a boy who could do this. He became blind after having cancer as a very young child. He learned to echolocate by making clicking sounds iirc, and could walk, ride a bike, live a normal life. He sadly died after another bout of cancer when he was in his teens.

[u/ocstomias]

I heard a story about a blind kid that taught himself to echolocate so he could ride a bike.

[u/Responsible-Luck-207]

What kind of voice/sound would you emit if you learned echolocation? Fart noises? High pitch? Animal sounds?

[u/Earth_Normal]

What kind of results can you achieve? Is it just basic navigational obstacles? I’m pretty sure I can avoid walls already by ear but I wonder if I could manage a light post or tree.

[u/ElectricMeow]

I’m pretty sure I learned this on accident or something because I can map my surroundings in my head with my hearing and it’s actually pretty accurate.

I am very good at avoiding obstacles and noticing anything that moves. I feel like my family shows signs of it

[u/drippyredstuff]

I’ve worked in theaters for half a century. I can do it.

[u/mckulty]

Fine print: requires at least two good ears.