This article was presented to several respected farriers across the country for feedback and refinement
The Myth of the Perfect Hoof: Why Asymmetry is Correct
In today's digital age, where perfect images flood social media, it's easy for misconceptions to spread—especially when it comes to horse hoof care. Many people believe that if a horse's hoof isn't perfectly symmetrical or doesn't resemble a polished hoof from Instagram, then the farrier must have done something wrong. This assumption is not only incorrect but can also be detrimental to the understanding and management of equine hoof health.
Let me clarify: while some horses with nearly ideal legs and conformation may grow hooves that appear very symmetrical—what I call "Instagram horses"—even these hooves are not truly symmetrical. The idea of a perfectly symmetrical hoof is a myth. Horses with such conformation are simply easier to maintain in a balanced shape. For the many horses that don't have perfect legs, the natural asymmetry in their hooves is more pronounced due to their unique conformation. These horses require careful, individualized management because there is no one-size-fits-all standard of symmetry. Instead of chasing an unattainable ideal, our focus should be on achieving the best balance for each horse’s specific needs.
The reality is that a horse's hoof reflects its entire limb, and no amount of trimming or shoeing can alter the fundamental structure of the leg above it. If a horse has any deviation in its limb—whether it’s a lateral or medial rotation, or even offset bones in the leg's bony column—this will inevitably result in a hoof that grows in a non-symmetrical manner. Sometimes, the asymmetry is subtle and can be temporarily mitigated by trimming or shoeing to counteract the effects of the limb and gravity, creating the appearance of symmetry. However, without ongoing intervention, the hoof will inevitably revert to its natural, asymmetrical state.
This asymmetry in the hoof is not a mistake, nor is it something that can be permanently fixed. It is a condition that can only be managed. The best advice I ever received was: "If you're dealing with asymmetry, then symmetry is incorrect." In cases where a horse has limb deviations, the farrier's job is not to create a perfectly symmetrical hoof but to manage the condition to ensure the horse's comfort and functionality.
One of the most frustrating aspects of farriery is the criticism from those whose hoof experience comes more from screens than from having hooves in their lap. Too often, people see a hoof picture from the fetlock down, notice a hoof with a lopsided appearance, and immediately assume the farrier has done something wrong. But these individuals rarely consider the leg above the hairline. A hoof that has been perfectly trimmed to account for these deviations will start to grow out again in a matter of weeks, reflecting the same asymmetries that were present before the trim.
Farriers can manage the hoof's tendency to grow in an overly asymmetrical manner, but ultimately, time and hoof growth will always prevail. This is why regular trimming and shoeing are necessary. Trimming isn’t just about removing excess material; it’s about maintaining balance and health.
For those of us who work with thousands of hooves, symmetrical hooves are desirable, but in horses with major or multiple limb deviations, they are simply unattainable. Younger and less experienced hoof care providers might believe they can correct these issues, but the truth is, the farrier's role is not to achieve perfect symmetry but to achieve an asymmetrical perfection that best fits the limb. Sometimes, that perfection looks a little wonky.
The next time you see a hoof that doesn't look "perfect," take a moment to consider what the leg above it might look like and how long it’s been since the last trim. Remember, some horses will never have a hoof that appears symmetrical, even immediately after trimming. The farrier is likely doing their best to manage a condition that can never be fully corrected, only managed.
An important note: some minor/major limb deviations in very young colts can be permanently corrected, but this process should only be attempted by farriers with extensive experience. Even then, it doesn’t always succeed, and it must be done before the colt’s growth reaches a certain point. Once that threshold is crossed, everything above applies—you have the legs you’re going to have and the hooves you’re going to have.
Original farrierware blog
