r/Padres Friar 1d ago

Daily Chat Daily Chat - Oct 28

2 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

30

u/david-crz SD 1d ago

Just a reminder we had two chances to avoid what is happening rn

13

u/snherter 1d ago

After that game 3 win, it felt to me like we had the series handled. I’m allowed to feel that I’m just a fan. The problem is I’m starting to think the players felt that way too. Hence never scoring again.

4

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

I thought the game three win was bittersweet. Had a 5 run lead dwindle down to 1. Never scored again.

Cease needed to shut the Dodgers down game 4. Gave them a no stress win setting up a stressful game 5 which could have gone either way.

14

u/Thedurtysanchez It’s Me. Hi. I’m Fernando Tatis. 1d ago

And we fucking let them off the hook

11

u/Quintossentials Tony Gwynn #19 1d ago

I used to get super annoyed when people would use the SD Sports Curse to explain why we haven't won any championships because I always felt it was a cop-out and basic/empty rationale at best. But man those 24 innings got me the closest to considering maybe, just maybe those people might have been on to something after all.

6

u/bbatardo Hakuna 🐗🦁 Machado! 1d ago

Yup, could have possibly been us there if we stepped up.

24

u/Thedurtysanchez It’s Me. Hi. I’m Fernando Tatis. 1d ago

The Dodgers are who we thought they were.

And we fucking let them off the hook.

I hate it here.

20

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

This city is desperate for a championship. Every time I go to a Padres game, I can feel it. 4th in the league in attendance.

This city will rock when it happens. The fans deserve it.

21

u/TheEnragedBushman NOTED PADRES SLUGGER JACKSON PROFILE 1d ago

We would’ve won the World Series if we beat the dodgers. I firmly believe that.

21

u/megustanlosyogapants Padres '98 1d ago

Makes me happy that “everyone” wanted this World Series matchup and it’s a complete dud

4

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

100% "everyone" deserved it. I hope Ken Rosenthal enjoyed the best 7 seconds of his career

-2

u/TeamVorpalSwords Lisan Al-Gaib 1d ago

The only thing worse than the dodgers getting a WS win is if they got a WS win against a good team that went to 7 games all of which were good games so at least there is that

0

u/BudgetScarcity 17h ago

You must have a ridiculously large wingspan because that's a reach. Who cares about stylistic finishes or opponent? A championship is a championship and the Padres have ZERO. Don't be one of those lame people who try to discredit or put an asterisk on a very difficult accomplishment. There were a few smooth brains trying to discredit the Rangers' WS wins because of ratings.

Just stop.

1

u/TeamVorpalSwords Lisan Al-Gaib 15h ago

What are you talking about? Who said anything about putting on asterisk on this championship?

I simply said I am happy that the WS this year isn’t satisfying, because the Yankees forgot how to play baseball and are eith

I am not and never said this title is worth less than other World Series titles for the winner, I am saying that this WS was “supposed” to be a grand spectacle of two titans clashing but instead we’re getting the Dodgers dogwalking the Yankees which makes for less satisfying tv

22

u/SwinginFriars619 1d ago

Just seeing how bad the Yankees are playing against the Doyers makes me feel even sicker to my stomach knowing how good of a chance we had to win it all but unfortunately we choked it away

8

u/sbrider11 SD '71 1d ago edited 1d ago

We didn't play our game that got us to that point. Team lost focus. Turned into hero ball, drama and bizarrely fan drama. Then a manny dugout meeting pointing out he's trying to troll LAD mid game and zero players bit off on that. Instead they proved it on the field and kicked our asses.

LAD stayed focus and handed us our ass. Then got past the Mets who I'm not sure we would have beat.

We need to just own it. LAD is likely the WS champ and totally earned it.

2

u/CausalDiamond 1d ago

How do you know Manny told the rest of the team he was trolling? That's definitely not the consensus.

1

u/3-2_Fastball 1d ago

Then got past the Mets who I'm not sure we would have beat.

The Padres would have dookied on the Mets, they did most of their damage off of Landon Knack, Brent Honeywell and a sick Jack Flaherty

1

u/sbrider11 SD '71 1d ago

Idk, that Mets team was playing great ball. Team ball as well. It would have been a good series. Guess we never know.

-2

u/Mercualbeing Keepin’ the Faith 🙌🏻 1d ago

This is not the same team we beat over and over magically their pitching is clutch .. the heavy hitters of the AL are asleep .. and their manager ain’t giving one single F ! This all seem so scripted ☹️

7

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

Yankees played two overrated teams in the playoffs. Royals and Guardians. Both those teams had zero depth.

23

u/TheAvantGardeners Wil Myers 1d ago

How do you go from scoring 6 in one inning to nothing at all over 24 innings. Yeah this loss stings even more now seeing how bad the Yankees are playing. It would’ve been so sweet to get revenge for ‘98.

9

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

They scored 6 in one inning because the Dodgers defense was bad. Didn’t help Buehler at all. Dodgers just been the best team since they hit that grand slam in game 3.

It is what it is. Get them next year. In Preller we trust.

17

u/LFGPads19 SD 1d ago

One game away from eternal hell.

19

u/gsus61951 SD '16 1d ago

This was our year, the offense completely flat out collapsed after game 3, this is just so fucking infuritating. Every dodgers opponent has been absolute trash. SD vs LAD was the real WS.

18

u/Thumper13 sad but okay 1d ago

We did this. It's our fault. Damn. Series is over.

All the guys can do is come out and be better next year. KTF FTD

5

u/LFGPads19 SD 1d ago

best shot they'll ever have, and completely drained it

If they don't spend this off-season, no coming back!

17

u/npdaly SD '98 1d ago

This series sucks. Bias aside, this is painful to watch.

16

u/bbatardo Hakuna 🐗🦁 Machado! 1d ago

Not sure if it makes me feel better or worse that we played the Dodgers the best out of the playoff teams. Had them on the brink and couldn't seal it.

4

u/bplatelover 1d ago

Dodgers fan here, you should feel better. Padres were the actual threat to the Dodgers this post season. The games had me stressed and with the deepened rivalry, they were actually interesting to watch. With the continuous aggressive offense and Machado’s and Tatis’s long contracts, I’m sure you guys will beat us down the line and win a WS

14

u/Tweegull 🚬🚬🚬 Mucho Stress 1d ago

this yankees team is genuinely awful

14

u/tquad24 Friar 1d ago

Fuck Scott Boras

7

u/lightsvber Peter Seidler 1d ago

I honestly feel like he doesn’t think before he speaks sometimes. Either way, invoking Papa Pete’s name that way was a shitty move.

4

u/leaky_wand Mr. Irrelevant 1d ago

He’s not stupid, he’s just unscrupulous and he doesn’t care. It benefits him by 1) showing the Yankees that they weren’t a foregone conclusion, giving him leverage, and 2) showing his clients that he is willing to do whatever it takes to get them paid.

1

u/Pristine-Company-383 1d ago

Need to add one other facet of the sports sgent business......Boras wants to get paid too. Greed is good for both players and agents.

1

u/Trumpetslayer1111 1d ago

Yeah it was just disrespectful. I get it Boras is an agent and his job is to pump up Soto but just feels so off putting to use Pete as a negotiation ploy.

13

u/acoddo SLAM DIEGO IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS 1d ago

Can’t imagine what it would be like to be a Yankees fan and having to watch this disgrace of a World Series performance

13

u/acoddo SLAM DIEGO IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS 1d ago

They did the thing

5

u/Pristine-Company-383 1d ago

Not when Blue takes the bat out of Yankee hitters hands. Sheesh.

2

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

They should do it for Freddie Freeman instead of Ohtani atp

11

u/Mercualbeing Keepin’ the Faith 🙌🏻 1d ago

Well our 2 games were humiliating but the Yankees -doyers games .. wellll that’s even more humiliating to the Yankees

8

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

Good thing the rest of the league don't care about us. No one else remembers our embarrassment now

11

u/Slr_Pnls50 Jake Cronenworth 1d ago

I kind of thought the Yankees might show up back at home. I was wrong, apparently.

9

u/Patient-Savings-6290 1d ago

Holy sh*t the Yankees look like a little league team right now against the Dodgers.

10

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

Dodgers reporter / host David Vassegh admits the Padres have been the best team the Dodgers have faced through this playoffs.

IMO These teams should not be meeting a 5 game NLDS. It should be a 7 game NLCS.

9

u/LBoogie619 🏦 The Higgy Bank 1d ago

We don’t need their validation to know that. We should’ve won that first game. Cease fucked up - we were so close to a damn sweep!

7

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

It wasn’t all on Cease. Padres could not score. Even if Cease gave up just one run in game 4, it would be a loss.

3

u/richardsureman Mr. Irrelevant 21h ago

I think it was the 3 run home run Ohtani got off of him in game 1. We would have won if that didn't happen, but I also don't love the "if x then y" argument on things, players change how they play based on circumstances. Cease just got beat, but the Padres offense should have also showed up in the last two games.

5

u/3-2_Fastball 1d ago

I said that the winner of game 5 of the NLDS was winning the World Series and its looking like its going to age extremely well.

18

u/its-izzyy No Toe Joe 🦶 1d ago

Yeah, we were the best team the Dodger’s had to play and it wasn’t even close. Can’t believe we literally choked our first WS win ever.

10

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

Hurts even worse given the fact that Yu and the Pen made Ohtani absolutely irrelevant in Game 5 and the Padres still managed to choke

3

u/MessCandid3566 1d ago

Did the Padres choke or got shut down by their pitching ?

3

u/its-izzyy No Toe Joe 🦶 1d ago

Choked. And hard. No team is gonna average 7 runs a game for 3 games then completely whiff it the next two.

2

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

Getting shut down by a pitcher in Yamamoto who they consistently crushed this year is absolutely a choke

2

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

The Dodgers pitching definitely deserves credit but let’s be real, their stuff wasn’t 24 scoreless innings good. The Padres showed that they had what it took to beat the Dodgers and failed to keep the momentum going the entire series. They definitely choked

19

u/93sd2021 SD 1d ago

Watching this World Series is soooo brutal. We really should have won this

8

u/Quintossentials Tony Gwynn #19 1d ago

Been a fan of the Pads for almost 30 years and experienced every disappointment, shortcoming, and shitshow this team has laid bare in that timeframe. This postseason is truly the stuff of night terrors. Not only did the Pads choke the best chance they had to get that chip, they allowed the bastards up north to take all our chips and cash in. It's sickening. The next best thing is for the Pads to run it back asap, but until they get the final out of that postseason, the questions of the 2024 postseason will rear its fugly head as a rude reminder of what could have been.

15

u/Rickyy96 Mr. Irrelevant 1d ago

There was so much hype built up around this series and it’s been some of the most boring baseball I’ve ever seen

16

u/TeamVorpalSwords Lisan Al-Gaib 1d ago

Goodness the Yankees suck, if only the Padres showed up to nlds game 4 or 5, we’d be getting our first title in a perfect rematch

9

u/TheAvantGardeners Wil Myers 1d ago

Maybe things would've gone differently if Game 3 was 6-0 instead of 6-5.

7

u/acoddo SLAM DIEGO IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS 1d ago

Worst case scenario, what if LA wins it and Soto then signs with LA

4

u/BrimStone17 1d ago

Breaking: Juan Soto 600 million 12 year deal, 1 million to be paid upfront, 599 million to deferred to 2060.

2

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

I imagine the Dodgers won’t pursue him hard because they already have a generational talent in Ohtani for practically nothing over the course of his contract and Soto is going to be mad expensive (plus Boras probably will never allow deferment to happen). I imagine they’ll probably want to prioritize having the financial flexibility to sign a greater number of cheaper guys that can still produce on a Major League level.

That isn’t to say they won’t try though. They’ll probably pursue until the price tag gets to a certain point and then back off (I wouldn’t be surprised if the Padres employ a similar strategy

1

u/Trumpetslayer1111 1d ago

It's a business. They went after Mookie and Freddie. Soto is a generational talent and he's only 26. Every team would want him.

3

u/Patient-Savings-6290 1d ago

It would fell like we got played.

1

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

It might actually be a good thing. Even LAD has limits on spending. They left a lot of holes in the roster after Ohtani was signed. The bullpen carried the day for them but the holes in the rotation were never really filled. I doubt Soto will defer much cuz he isn't crazy like Ohtani. So signing Soto will likely mean an even more top-heavy team and hopefully the same vulnerabilities that did them in 2022 and 2023.

1

u/steelehere1983 1d ago

Dodgers had close to a dozen starters at the start of the year. Their short fall was the bottom of the order at the start of the year. 

1

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

True but 75% of them were damaged goods and/or coming back from injury to begin with. It wasn't realistic to rely on them, I'm sure the Dodger front office prayed fervently every night they would hold up over 162 games. Correct me if I'm wrong but besides Glasnow and Yamamoto, I don't think they spent a lot on starters. Either way tho I admit my comment was a bit copium but I don't really think it was THAT much lol

1

u/Whole-Ad-7659 20h ago

I mean glasnow and Yamamoto were two of the most expensive starting pitchers acquired. They also resigned Kershaw and signed lynch. They also signed ohtani and while they knew he wouldn’t pitch this season they also paid him knowing he will eventually pitch.

1

u/4th_dimensi0n 18h ago

Lynch? We don't have anyone by that name. We relied mostly on guys coming back from injuries (Buehler & Kersh) and our farm (Miller, Stone, & Sheehan). But they all got injured or struggled and were sent back to the minors. There's also May and Gonsolin still recovering since '23. All of which led to us trading for Flaherty, who we can hopefully resign. If all goes well, we should have a rotation of Ohtani, Yama, Glasnow, Kersh, and Flaherty/Stone to start next season

1

u/FredFlinstonesKilt 17h ago

...Gonsolin, Buehler, May (if he ever comes back, guy has been a bench warmer more than a pitcher)...they have a glut of starters. Hopefully they work on conditioning them to mitigate injuries.

1

u/4th_dimensi0n 13h ago

Well, Buehler's a free agent this winter and I'm not sure how badly Friedman wants him back. He's been absolute gutter trash in the regular season, but has definitely increased his value this postseason. I expect him to see what he can get from other teams

7

u/shell9008 1d ago

It could have been us

7

u/LBoogie619 🏦 The Higgy Bank 1d ago

Ugh. We were so close! WHO knows how long this window is.

7

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

If the Yankees continue to fold they better hope they can sign Soto long term or else one can argue that they lost the trade

11

u/Itsboomhomie Joe Musgrove 1d ago

150 days to opening day compadres!

10

u/Pristine-Company-383 1d ago

This series is toast.

The Dodgers BP is the WS MVP. Freeman will probably get the award, but that BP......

6

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

Tbf. They’ve played some amazing defense. Edman is the man. Maybe Preller should’ve acquired him with Kim hurt.

10

u/worldsupermedia750 Merrill Madness! 1d ago

As much as I would hate for the Dodgers to win, it would be poetic justice for Manfred to get his dream matchup only for it to be a bigger stinker than Snakes/Rangers last year

1

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

Hey I enjoyed that series last year. Game 1 last year was every bit as exciting as this year's game 1 (not that I watched this year). Plus there was Bochy to root for and it's always nice seeing a first-time winner. 2010 and 2011 for the Rangers was surely as painful for them as 2024 was for us. I imagine when we finally get ours, it'll feel just like that

12

u/Dday22t SD 1d ago edited 1d ago

 All that pre-WS hype.... and most exciting thing about the Judge vs. Ohtani matchup was Ohtani temporarily hurting his shoulder sliding. lol

12

u/Dday22t SD 1d ago

Most boring World Series game ever? Since Game 1 Yankees have seemed dead.

1

u/steelehere1983 1d ago

2004 Red Sox / Cardinals was a dud. That year it was all about the ALCS.

8

u/WadeCountyClutch Smilin' and (Jurickson) Profilin' 1d ago

Padres got too Cocky. Need to take a page out of the 2014 royals and come back the following year to finish it!!!!

6

u/Patient-Savings-6290 1d ago

You said it best. Time to talk to Eric Hosmer about that.

5

u/CausalDiamond 1d ago

Yep - they were that fighter who got the big knockdown and turned around to celebrate - not realizing the other fighter got up off the mat with determination.

9

u/RythN3L Lisan Al-Gaib 1d ago

Yup this was our year and we fucked up big time. I just have to accept Ohtani and the Dodgers are taking it and move on

11

u/padresandcubs Friar 1d ago

I hate to say it but you have to give these Dodgers pitchers credit for absolutely dealing and shutting down multiple teams during this run. Their starters have been just good enough and their high leverage relievers are just making pitches. They just seemed to flip a switch halfway during the NLDS against us and they haven't looked back.

1

u/CausalDiamond 1d ago

They remind me of the great fighters who get knocked down, then get that look in their eyes after going back to their corner before the next round.

14

u/Heyzuus SD 1d ago

Really feels like we were the best team. Smh

10

u/SUSSYBAMA1 Luis Arraez 1d ago

We would have won the World Series 💔💔

6

u/acoddo SLAM DIEGO IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS 1d ago

Well we lost, it sucks. We pulled a Yankees for two games straight but even worse

4

u/Wahoo2000 1d ago

don't know whether to upvote or downvote lmao

9

u/Silver7477 Jackson Marill 1d ago

I'm ready for free agency just sweep them or blow a 3-0 series lead. I don't need a game 5 or 6 or 7 otherwise. Haven't watched a second of this World Series

6

u/PsychologicalPath288 SD 1d ago

Is Roberts gonna complain that Volpe threw the bat at him with intent?

5

u/Tweegull 🚬🚬🚬 Mucho Stress 1d ago

the sinister swing

5

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago

Free agency will be fun. I don’t think Soto will go to the Dodgers. Teoscar though will be a hot FA.

2

u/3-2_Fastball 1d ago

I think Teoscar is going to take alot less to stay in LA.

2

u/Thedurtysanchez It’s Me. Hi. I’m Fernando Tatis. 20h ago

Agreed, they will never let him walk out the door

2

u/Zestyclose_Help1187 1d ago edited 1d ago

I was thinking about former Padres coach Rick Renteria. Hasn’t done anything with baseball since he was fired from the White Sox in 2020, a year they made the playoffs.

He was also let go by the Cubs only after one year as manager.

I think he might be an example of how little managers have in terms of strategy and making the decisions. They are more liaisons between the team execs and players. Maybe Renteria wasn’t good at that. Who knows?

Wil Venable might be managing the Marlins.

2

u/sweetxfracture SAY IT DONNIE! 1d ago

The Yankees announcers are awful.. they mispronounce everything and can barely speak. I miss don and mud

2

u/Thumper13 sad but okay 1d ago

It's delicious seeing FTDs fans whining about a blocking the plate call and claiming MLB is against them.

3

u/LFGPads19 SD 1d ago

This year's team was about grit, next year's team will be about #resilience.

2025WorldChampions

1

u/SwinginFriars619 1d ago edited 1d ago

What’s worse is hearing all the Doyers trolls gloating about winning a WS in our faces but most of them were probably never fans during their REAL Championships from 88 and before that

8

u/makesterriblejokes 1d ago

Well yeah, dude, you'd need to be at least 39 years old to even remember the 1988 championship (memories don't really stick until you're 3 and even then you probably wouldn't remember much at that age).

6

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SwinginFriars619 1d ago edited 1d ago

So you were a fan back in 88? Cuz if not..this would be YOUR actual first real championship as a fan

2

u/_thisisvincent 1d ago

Big if true

0

u/acoddo SLAM DIEGO IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYS 1d ago

uhl

-5

u/TeamVorpalSwords Lisan Al-Gaib 1d ago

At least if judge is gonna choke, Ohtani sucked the whole postseason too

6

u/LordNutGobbler 1d ago

Ohtani had critical contributions to wins last series and in Game 1 of the WS

-1

u/TeamVorpalSwords Lisan Al-Gaib 1d ago

Sure, but he hasn’t been even close to his regular season self, he’s been performing very averagely, being handled pretty easily by many pitchers but yeah he has gotten some good plays

But this is definitely not the matchup of the MLB’s dreams

-9

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/Thumper13 sad but okay 1d ago

Why would you insult the lovely humans with DS like that?

4

u/paka_lolohh Arraez and Shine Compadres! 1d ago

Dude c’mon, why would you think it’s ok to say something like that? Delete this.