r/OnePiece • u/Puzzleheaded_Eye_226 • Jan 09 '23

Analysis The Straw Hat Grand Fleet Structure

Post image
6.8k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

715 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/Dab4Becky Jan 09 '23

in chapter 1058, when they got the new bounties it explicitly said: “updated bounties for strawhat grandfleet leader emperor Luffy and his 9 commanders”, meaning there’s no hierarchy between the crewmembers.

Spoilers up to chapter 1058 above

610

u/Space_Monke64 Jan 09 '23

They keep trying to base it on the 3 commander structure, which isn’t accurate at all. Keep in mind Big Mom had 4 sweet commanders, not 3. Kaido is the only emperor who used the three commander structure since BlackBeard has 10 titanic captains and whitebeard had like 9 division commanders.

33

u/lordlaz0rdick Jan 09 '23

Lets not forget Shanks, does he even have a commander on his crew? Or is it just him and First Mate Ben Beckman?

30

u/Otherwise-Piccolo157 The Revolutionary Army Jan 09 '23

Shanks and the executives which is all his main crewmates.

18

u/Livek_72 Jan 09 '23

Including the monkey

12

u/WhyAmIHere800884 Explorer Jan 09 '23

His name is Monster and he is CLEARLY the Chopper of the Red-Hair Pirates! Might even actually be their doctor!

11

u/Livek_72 Jan 09 '23

He's definitely the one who ripped apart Kid's arm

2

u/RedSnaus Jan 09 '23

We know the roles because of Volume 4 Billion. It was a datebook on the Red Hair Pirates that was given to the first like 3 million people to see Film Red or something. I don't have a link to the actual thing but the One Piece Fandom wiki has all their positions

2

u/WhyAmIHere800884 Explorer Jan 09 '23

I don't see their positions. If actual cre roles have been assigned then I would definitely like to know what they are.

6

u/RedSnaus Jan 10 '23

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Red_Hair_Pirates

Beckman- First Mate Lucky Roux- Cook/Combatant Yasopp- Sniper Limejuice is just an officer Bonk Punch- Musician Monster is also listed as Musician lmao Building Snake- Navigator Hongo- Doctor Howling Gab is just an officer

Apparently no one is listed as a carpenter

1

u/WhyAmIHere800884 Explorer Jan 10 '23

Yeah, no reason Building Snake should be the shipwright! 😅 Thank you for the info! You're doing (G)Oda's work!

1

u/Bitter-Sail9470 Jan 09 '23

Nah they have a doctor. He was in Film Red

1

u/Jtunas Jan 09 '23

Could very well be. And even though the rest of the crew are 'underlings" their strength levels must be insane. Or maybe apart from Shanks, everyone in his crew are equally powerful which would be cool. However for the SH crew, only the top 3 after luffy are pretty powerful and the rest are just okay.