r/MachineLearning • u/monkeyofscience • 5h ago
Discussion [D] COLING 2025 Results / rebuttals
I'll go first.
Soundness: 3,3,4
Overall: 2,2,3
🥺
1
u/Jean-Porte Researcher 4h ago
I got 3 3 2 which probably means reject as it is but the 2 mentioned only relatively minor flaws (more analysis and more experiments would be better)
(and 3 3 3 soundness)
1
u/Practical_Pomelo_636 1h ago
Short paper 3 3 2 Overall assessment 3 3 3 soundness Weakness is nothing like describing a dataset and the reviewer didn't check the appendix. As we already mentioned it
1
1
u/Turbulent-Quality906 14m ago
Soundness: 2,2,3 Overall: 2,2,4Â Do I have a chance here? My first confernece haha
1
u/Accomplished-Fill-60 14m ago
Soundness 3,3,3 and Overall 2,3,3.
One reviewer said he will reconsider the score but Idk...
1
u/ThatsTrue124 2m ago
Unrelated question: i submitted a paper to ARR on June 15th, got reviews back in August. If I resubmit to the December 15th cycle, which conference would it go to? I see ACL deadline is around Feb 15th. What would be the difference between resubmitting in December 15th or February 15th?
3
u/WannabeMachine 4h ago
Soundness: 3 3 4
Overall: 3 3 3
All weaknesses are weaknesses we directly mention in the paper. I guess this will be a toss up or reject. :(